International student tuition and the funding crisis to come

One does not need to be an oracle to read the future in the cracking bones of the United States higher education system. The combination of reduced state support, increasing reliance on tuition fee revenue and decreasing domestic and international enrolment is coalescing into a hulking morass.

In 2017, inflation-adjusted state appropriation for higher education was down 10% from the decade prior and marked the first year that tuition fee funding eclipsed educational appropriations in the majority of states, according to a report by the State Higher Education Executive Officers Association. 

While tuition fee increases have supplemented state support, it has come at a high price for students in the form of US$1.5 trillion of debt and economic preclusion from tertiary education. 

From the 2012-13 to the 2017-18 academic year, domestic enrolment declined 8.3% (according to National Center for Education Statistics data) as the gap between investment and its return widened.

International students have become increasingly important tools in the uphill battle to combat declining domestic enrolment and state support. While domestic enrolment peaked and then decreased consistently since the 2012-13 academic year, the breadth of total enrolment drops has been mitigated by international student enrolment, which increased 33.6% over the same period, according to data from the Institute of International Education.

International students, who pay on average three times more than their domestic counterparts, provide crucial financial resources to higher education institutions and constitute the majority of graduate students in STEM courses – science, technology, engineering and mathematics.

A dangerous game

Increasing reliance on international student tuition fees is the catalyst for transforming international higher education in the US from a diplomatic enterprise to the financial linchpin of strategic plans. 

Couched in a hybrid language of college counselling and business vernacular, the discourse surrounding international student recruitment is morphing more into the latter as students become ‘customers’ and the failure to attract them falls on the institutions, which are unable to meet the demands of a market-based higher education system into which they are unwittingly thrust. 

Aware of the writing on the wall, US higher education institutions now scour the globe in order to subsidise and supplement funding in an increasingly crowded market for recruiting international students.

The problem with this approach is that it only works until it doesn’t. The strategy of increasing tuition fees and searching far and wide for more students to pay it, hits a point of diminishing returns. Tuition revenue from a dwindling pool of students will not only shrink, but its consequences will (and do) reverberate throughout society and the economy as the population of college-educated Americans reduces and the level of student debt grows.

Complex problems and simple solutions

The dual decline of domestic and international student enrolment and the impending financial consequences expose the short-sightedness of the tuition-fee-based funding model. 

Having failed the viability test on the domestic front, we’ve exported this model globally in the hope that international students will continue to fund and populate college campuses regardless of the cost. With new international enrolment declining 6.6% this year (according to the Institute of International Education), it’s hard to make the case that it will.

It is an American predilection to believe that we can fix systemic problems through the same mechanisms that cause them. We are told that we can fix our healthcare system through greater exposure to the market, that our costly and overcrowded prisons should be privatised, that our universities need to better mirror the private sector with its quenchless thirst for financial capital. 

As a result, we lead the world in healthcare costs and incarceration. Our colleges and universities, the most expensive in the world, are at risk of falling into the same category of systemic rot.

The ramifications of diminished financial resources and fewer students is clear. The recent spate of school closures, both for- and non-profit, is symptomatic of the problems facing the US higher education system. Institutions shut down en masse, the quality of education suffers, resulting in greater decreases in enrolment, thus deepening the problem.

Rather than resign ourselves to the status quo, there is a responsibility to tackle the problem head on and save our most valuable and resilient institution – the university. To do this, we need to be honest about the causes of high tuition fees, from the construction of Babylonian campuses, to our increasing willingness to look the other way as state support dwindles.

International students, some of the best and the brightest in the world, bring us diversity and exposure to new cultures. They leave as ambassadors for American education and thought. They are not a panacea for the financial woes of our colleges and universities, morally or practically speaking.

Source

Table of Contents

Germany needs international students

CHE Ranking 2019: the most comprehensive and detailed ranking of universities from German-speaking countries

Russia and Spain agreed on mutual diploma recognition

Type of university is unbiased

First Chinese-language testing center opened in Pyongyang, North Korea

Business School of RANEPA received prestigious world accreditation

Turkey abolishes limit on international students numbers at universities

Scientists at Nazarbayev University made a world discovery in physics

Government of Russia approved the rules for allocating grants for "Export of Education" activities

Scientists from NEFU and Sooam Foundation continue joint research on the cloning of an ancient foal

6,700 rural students will receive free medical education in China

The 73rd International Youth Scientific Conference "Oil and Gas-2019"

CALL FOR PROPOSALS: 10th Anniversary International Russian Higher Education Conference (RHEC)

Chinese Academy of Engineering to add new members

MSU to be site of first of 15 ‘Technological Valleys’

Ministerial summit will be held during WorldSkills Kazan 2019

Draft-bill on the functioning of the Kazakhstan branch of Moscow State University named after M.V. Lomonosov reviewed

EduTraC Oman 2019

Magdalena Gaete: "University Reputation Is a Perceived Quality"

Registration CAIE 2019 second webinar

Всемирный доклад по мониторингу образования-2019 представили на прошедшем Московском международном салоне образования

Scottish Government extends free tuition for EU students

Round University Ranking 2019 has been released

Россия заняла второе место в рейтинге RUR по числу представленных вузов

Новый глобальный рейтинг университетов Times Higher Education (THE)

The Robert S. McNamara Fellowships Program 2019

The Japanese government will create national information center (NIC) to increase the chances of students to study abroad

Scientist from China can take the lead of a new research center in the Urals

Dmitry Medvedev: the number of universities participating in the Project 5-100 will be increased

School graduation exams abolished in Georgia

Публикационная активность России по данным Scopus и Web of Science

BAYHOST Mobility Grants 2019

Russian Science Foundation in cooperation with the Ministry of Science and Technology of Taiwan (MOST) announces open public competition to receive research grants

Экспорт российских образовательных услуг

Export of Russian educational services: Statistical Collection

UniRank published Top 200 Universities on instagram

В госпрограмму развития образования внесены изменения

Эксперты ВНИИ труда определили наиболее высокооплачиваемые профессии и самые стабильные сферы работы в России

UniRank published Top 200 Universities on Twitter

Recognition of foreign diplomas simplified in Uzbekistan

К 2024 году приём на бюджетные места по программам IT-специальностей будет увеличен в пять раз

Правительство РФ утвердило правила предоставления грантов

МГУ имени М. В. Ломоносова вошел в топ-100 лучших университетов мира по версии QS

Education in the United Arab Emirates

Prof. Dr. Galina Motova was elected APQN Vice-President

Педагогов научат, как себя вести, и доплатят «за вредность»

Рособрнадзор опубликовал список нарушений вузов при аккредитации

Вузовская библиотека нового века – куда ведут пути развития

Beijing Institute of Technology and Francisk Skorina Gomel State University will expand scientific cooperation

What awaits Cypriot students studying in England after Brexit?